Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles: Which Is Right for Your Central Washington Home or Business?

If you’re standing at the crossroads of a roof replacement, here’s the short answer: asphalt shingles cost less upfront and suit most standard residential roofs, while metal roofing costs more initially but lasts two to three times longer and handles Central Washington’s extreme temperature swings, wind, and snow load better over the long run. For most homeowners on a budget, architectural asphalt shingles remain the practical choice. For commercial buildings, long-term owners, and anyone tired of replacing a roof every 20 years, standing seam metal is increasingly the smarter investment — especially with what our winters and summers put roofs through in the Yakima Valley.

That’s the quick version. The real answer depends on your building type, your budget, how long you plan to own the property, and how much punishment your roof takes from our specific climate. Let’s break it down properly.

As a roofing and gutter contractor that’s worked on homes and commercial buildings across the Yakima Valley since 1968, we’ve installed, repaired, and replaced enough roofs of both types to know that the “right” answer really does depend on your specific situation — not a one-size-fits-all recommendation.

The Real Question: What Does Your Roof Need to Survive?

Every roofing material decision should start with a simple question: what is this roof actually up against? In Central Washington, that’s not a rhetorical question — it’s a checklist.

Our region sees triple-digit summer heat, sub-freezing winter nights, occasional heavy snow loads, wind events that funnel through the Yakima Valley and Kittitas Valley corridors, and the kind of freeze-thaw cycling that punishes roofing materials more than steady cold or steady heat ever would. A roof here isn’t just shedding rain like it might in Seattle — it’s expanding and contracting through 80-plus degree temperature swings between winter nights and summer afternoons, sometimes within the same week.

That’s the backdrop for every metal-vs-asphalt conversation we have with homeowners and business owners. If you haven’t already, it’s worth reading our deeper dive on best roofing materials for Central Washington weather, which covers how different materials perform across our specific climate zones. This article focuses specifically on the metal vs. asphalt decision.

Wood cabin with metal roof surrounded by gardens and forested hills

Problem → Cause → Solution: Breaking Down the Real Tradeoffs

Rather than a generic pros-and-cons list, let’s walk through the actual problems each material solves — and creates — in our climate.

Problem 1: Asphalt Shingles Degrade Faster in High UV and Heat

The Problem: Homeowners often find that shingles installed 12–15 years ago are already curling, losing granules, or cracking, well short of their advertised 20–30 year lifespan.

The Cause: Central Washington gets intense, high-elevation UV exposure combined with summer surface temperatures on a south- or west-facing roof that can exceed 150°F. Asphalt is a petroleum-based product, and repeated heat cycling dries out the asphalt binder, causing granules to loosen and shingles to become brittle. Add in our low humidity, and the drying effect is even more pronounced than in coastal climates where shingles are rated.

The Solution: Choose a high-quality architectural (dimensional) shingle with a strong UV/heat rating rather than a builder-grade three-tab shingle, and make sure attic ventilation is adequate — poor ventilation traps heat against the underside of the roof deck and accelerates shingle aging from below. If you’re set on asphalt, this single decision (ventilation) often has more impact on lifespan than the shingle brand itself. Alternatively, metal roofing reflects a significant portion of solar radiation and doesn’t rely on an oil-based binder, so it isn’t subject to the same UV degradation.

Problem 2: Snow Load and Ice Damming

The Problem: Heavy, wet snow sits on the roof, then partially melts and refreezes at the eaves, forming ice dams that back water up under shingles and into the roof deck.

The Cause: Ice damming happens when heat escaping from the attic melts snow on the upper roof while the eaves — which overhang unheated space — stay cold. The meltwater refreezes at the edge, building a dam that traps standing water against the shingles. Asphalt shingles are not designed to hold back standing water; they’re designed to shed moving water. Once water sits, it finds a way in.

The Solution: Metal roofing’s smooth, slick surface sheds snow far more readily (sometimes in dramatic slides, which needs to be accounted for in design near walkways and entries). For asphalt roofs in snow-prone areas of Kittitas and Yakima counties, proper attic insulation and ventilation to keep the roof deck uniformly cold, along with ice-and-water shield membrane at the eaves, is essential. Gutter and downspout capacity also matters here — undersized or clogged gutters make ice damming worse, which is where proper gutter sizing and maintenance becomes part of the roofing conversation, not a separate issue.

Problem 3: Wind Uplift on Exposed and Open-Land Properties

The Problem: Shingles lift, curl at the edges, or blow off entirely during wind events, particularly on homes and outbuildings in more exposed, open areas of the valley.

The Cause: Standard asphalt shingles rely on an adhesive sealant strip that bonds shingle courses together after installation, activated by heat. In a new installation before that seal has fully set, or on an older roof where the seal has broken down, wind can get underneath the shingle edge and peel it back. Central Washington’s wind corridors, especially around the Yakima River canyon and open agricultural land, generate sustained gusts that exceed what standard-grade shingles are rated for.

The Solution: For wind-prone properties, upgrade to a shingle with a higher wind rating and confirm proper nailing pattern during installation (this is one of the most common installation defects we find). Metal roofing panels, when properly fastened with concealed clips or exposed fasteners rated for the application, offer significantly higher wind uplift resistance because the panels interlock and fasten mechanically rather than relying on adhesive.

Problem 4: Long-Term Cost of Repeated Replacement

The Problem: Property owners — especially commercial owners — find themselves budgeting for a full roof replacement every 18–22 years, and the disruption, labor cost, and material cost keep climbing each cycle.

The Cause: Asphalt shingles have a finite service life, and in our climate that life often runs shorter than the manufacturer’s rating due to the UV and freeze-thaw factors above. Every replacement also means tear-off labor, disposal, and re-decking if the substrate has degraded.

The Solution: Metal roofing systems commonly last 40–70 years depending on the product, meaning a single installation can outlast two or three asphalt replacement cycles. For commercial buildings especially, where roof access, tenant disruption, and labor costs during replacement are significant, the total cost of ownership over a 40-year window frequently favors metal even though the upfront material and installation cost is higher.

Hillside home overlooking a river valley and rugged mountains

Residential Perspective

For most single-family homes in the Yakima Valley, the decision usually comes down to how long you plan to stay in the home and what your upfront budget allows.

If you’re planning to sell within 5–10 years, a quality architectural asphalt shingle is typically the more cost-effective choice. It has broad buyer familiarity, lower upfront cost, and a wide range of colors and styles that match traditional home aesthetics. Most Central Washington neighborhoods are still asphalt-dominant, so a shingle roof won’t stand out from comparable homes on an appraisal.

If you’re building new, doing a major renovation, or planning to stay long-term, metal roofing is worth serious consideration. Standing seam and metal shingle products have matured significantly in residential applications — they’re no longer limited to the corrugated barn-style look, and many products now mimic shake or shingle profiles while delivering metal’s durability. Homeowners with steep-pitch roofs, homes near open fields exposed to wind, or properties where snow load and ice damming have historically caused problems tend to see the fastest payoff from switching to metal.

One residential consideration specific to our area: homes in the foothills and higher-elevation parts of Kittitas County see more snow accumulation than valley-floor homes in Yakima proper. That difference alone can shift the calculus toward metal, even for two homes just 20 miles apart.

Commercial Perspective

Commercial roofing decisions run on a different set of priorities: total cost of ownership, minimizing business disruption, insurance and code considerations, and — often — the roof’s role in energy costs.

For low-slope and flat commercial roofs common on retail, warehouse, and office buildings, the metal-vs-asphalt comparison usually isn’t shingle-vs-standing-seam; it’s more often about metal roofing systems versus membrane or built-up roofing, which is a related but distinct conversation. For commercial buildings with steeper pitches — agricultural buildings, some retail storefronts, and pitched-roof office buildings common around Yakima and Ellensburg — the same core tradeoffs from this article apply directly.

A few commercial-specific factors worth weighing:

  • Downtime and disruption. A metal roof replacement or overlay can sometimes be installed with less tear-off mess and disruption to business operations than a full asphalt tear-off and re-roof, particularly for retrofit applications.
  • Insurance and financing. Some commercial insurers offer more favorable terms for metal roofs given their wind and fire resistance, and the longer service life can factor into financing and depreciation schedules.
  • Energy costs. Reflective metal roofing can meaningfully reduce cooling loads during our long, hot summers, which matters for large-footprint commercial buildings with significant HVAC costs.
  • Maintenance contracts. Commercial property managers often prefer the more predictable, lower-frequency maintenance profile of metal over the granule loss, patching, and periodic recoating that asphalt and built-up systems require.

For any commercial roofing project, proper installation matters even more than on residential jobs, given the scale, the code requirements, and the cost of getting it wrong.

Cost Considerations

Rough cost ranges (material and installation combined) for the Central Washington market:

  • Asphalt shingles (architectural/dimensional): Generally the lower upfront cost per square, with a wide range depending on shingle grade, roof complexity, and tear-off needs.
  • Metal roofing (standing seam or metal shingle): Typically runs meaningfully higher upfront than asphalt — often close to double, depending on the panel profile and gauge — but with a service life two to three times longer.

The way to compare them fairly isn’t sticker price — it’s cost per year of service life. A metal roof that costs roughly double an asphalt roof but lasts three times as long is, on paper, the better long-term value. What changes the calculation is your time horizon: if you won’t own the property long enough to benefit from that longevity, the lower upfront cost of asphalt often wins. If you’re building for the long haul, or you’re a commercial owner thinking in decades rather than years, metal’s total cost of ownership usually comes out ahead.

Other cost factors that apply to both materials:

  • Roof pitch and complexity — more valleys, dormers, and penetrations increase labor cost regardless of material.
  • Tear-off vs. overlay — removing an old roof versus installing over it (where code allows) changes the price significantly.
  • Decking condition — if the roof deck has water damage or has degraded, replacement adds cost no matter which material you choose.
  • Gutter and drainage upgrades — metal roofs shed water faster and in higher volume during storms, which sometimes means upsizing gutters and downspouts to keep pace, an added cost worth budgeting for during a metal roof install.

Central Washington Weather: What Actually Drives This Decision

It’s worth restating plainly because it’s the core of this whole comparison: our climate is genuinely different from the coastal and marine climates that a lot of generic roofing content is written for.

  • Wide daily and seasonal temperature swings stress asphalt’s adhesive bond and binder more than steady climates do.
  • Low humidity and intense UV accelerate asphalt aging beyond its rated lifespan.
  • Snow load in higher-elevation and foothill areas favors metal’s shedding capability.
  • Wind corridors through the valley put a premium on wind-rated materials and correct installation.
  • Hot, dry summers make reflective roofing (a metal strength) relevant for cooling costs.

None of this means asphalt is a bad choice in Central Washington — millions of roofs here are asphalt and perform fine when properly installed and ventilated. It means the margin for installation error is smaller here than in milder climates, and the case for metal’s durability is stronger here than in regions with more moderate weather.

Continuous Gutter & Roofing Co. Team

When to Call a Professional

Some parts of this decision you can research on your own. Others genuinely require an experienced eye on your specific roof, and getting them wrong is expensive. Call a professional roofer when:

  • You’re not sure if your roof deck or structure can support metal roofing. Metal is generally lighter than asphalt per square, but panel type and underlayment requirements vary, and older structures sometimes need evaluation.
  • You’re seeing signs of ice damming, active leaks, or granule loss in your gutters — these are symptoms that need a proper inspection to find the actual cause, not just a patch.
  • You’re comparing quotes and the numbers don’t add up. A wide spread between bids for the same material is often a sign of differences in underlayment, ventilation work, flashing detail, or shortcuts that won’t show up until years later.
  • You’re planning a commercial project involving code compliance, insurance requirements, or multiple roof sections with different needs.
  • You want a real cost-per-year comparison for your specific roof rather than generic averages, since roof complexity, pitch, and current condition all change the math.
  • Your existing roof is nearing the end of its expected life and you want an honest assessment of whether it needs full replacement now or can be maintained a few more years.

A qualified local roofer will also know things generic guides can’t tell you — like which neighborhoods see the worst ice damming, which manufacturers’ products hold up best to our specific UV exposure, and how local wind patterns should influence your fastening and underlayment choices.

Continuous Gutter & Roofing has been assessing and repairing roofs across the Yakima Valley since 1968, and we’ve seen firsthand how our local climate affects both asphalt and metal roofs differently from one neighborhood to the next. If any of the situations above sound like your roof, contact us for an inspection or quote — we’ll give you a straight answer on what your roof actually needs, not just a sales pitch for whichever material is easiest to install.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is metal roofing actually worth the extra upfront cost in Central Washington? 

For most homeowners planning to stay long-term, and for nearly all commercial property owners, yes. Metal’s 40–70 year lifespan against asphalt’s realistic 15–25 year performance in our climate means metal often has a lower cost per year of service, even with a higher installation price.

Will a metal roof make my house hotter or colder? 

No — in fact, metal roofing typically reduces summer cooling costs because it reflects more solar radiation than asphalt. With proper insulation, it performs at least as well as asphalt in winter, and reflective coatings can be specified for even better summer performance.

Is metal roofing noisy during rain or hail? 

Not with proper installation. Modern metal roofing is installed over solid decking with underlayment, which absorbs sound the same way it does under asphalt shingles. The “noisy tin roof” reputation comes from older barn-style installations over open framing without decking.

Can I install metal roofing directly over my existing asphalt shingles? 

In some cases, yes, where local code and roof condition allow it, which can reduce cost and disruption. However, it depends on the existing roof’s condition, weight considerations, and code requirements, so this needs a professional assessment rather than a general answer.

Which material handles Central Washington snow better? 

Metal roofing sheds snow more effectively due to its smooth surface, which reduces the risk of ice damming and excess weight load. This matters more for higher-elevation and foothill properties than for valley-floor homes, where snow load is typically lighter.

Scroll to Top